Season 6 has finally wrapped and I am still trying to find the right way to recap my thoughts on this finale and the season as a whole. If you read my blog, you know that I wasn’t a huge fan of this season. I just felt there was little direction as to what the true end game was. Usually when we start a season of Supernatural, the mission is clear..finding the yellow eyed demon that killed their mother and destroying him, saving Dean from having to go to hell (as a result of a deal he made with a cross roads demon to save Sam), stopping Lilith and preventing Lucifer from rising, stop the apocalypse. This season wasn’t so clear-cut. At first it was figuring out who/what Sam is, then it was fighting Crowley in his quest for souls in Purgatory, then it was the Mother of All, and in the background was the war in Heaven. Usually, one of those is the main arc for the season with the others contributing to the main arc or stand alone as side stories. But it was never clear what the MAIN arc was. It seems to me at this point, it was the war in Heaven all along with Castiel trying to find a way to stop Raphael from taking over and destroying the world. Now why couldn’t that have been laid out to us earlier on in the season instead of waiting until episode 20 of 22 to tell us? There still would have been mystery and intrigue as to what was going on and how Castiel was going to stop Raphael and how Crowley, Eve, the souls,and the Winchesters all tied in. But instead, I watched this season very confused as to what I was supposed to care about. Now maybe I’m a complete idiot (which is very likely) and should have seen all this coming a mile away, but I didn’t. I knew Cas and Raph were at odds but I didn’t know why. And the war in Heaven always seemed like an after thought. So much for that being the case I guess. Hence my season long frustration. I talked with some people in the comments section about this. While I think there were some great individual standout episodes this season (Frontierland is one of my all time favorite episodes), the episodes didn’t seem to mesh well into a season long success for me. I kept saying that I had faith they would pull it together for the finale. While it was pulled together, the result didn’t really have much impact for me the way it did in other seasons.
Let me touch on the one aspect that worked well before I get into the other stuff. I like the way they handled Sam rebuilding his soul piece by piece. I’m glad they didn’t forget about that since it was several episodes ago when Death gave Sam his soul back and put up the wall that he told him not to scratch it. Castiel needed to find a way to distract Dean from trying to stop him, so he took down Sam’s wall, leaving him in a coma with Dean and Bobby unaware of how they can help him. Cas promises to return to help Sam but with the decisions Cas has been making lately, Dean and Bobby aren’t so sure. They get a lead on stopping Cas and Crowley but Dean doesn’t want to leave Sam. He does because he knows that’s what Sam would want and leaves him a note and a gun (who doesn’t leave their love ones a gun when running out to do an errand I ask) letting him know where they are in case he wakes up. He wakes up alright but not before some crazy inner fighting that happens between him and a few other “Sams.”
In order for Sam to wake up and become COMPLETELY himself again, he needs to fight Soulless Sam and Hell Really Kicked the Shit Out of Me Sam. Here’s my question though…and please tell me if you had the same question or if I am reading too much into this….was Sam fighting the other 2 portions of his soul to see who would be the dominate soul when this was all said and done? So if Soulless Sam beat Sam and Hell Really Kicked the Shit Out of Me Sam, Soulless Sam is who we would get but he would have the memories of the other two? So that’s why Sam had to fight them? I always assumed that when the wall came down, it just meant that Sam remembered everything. So I took what happened to mean that he had to fight his own inner demons to “win out” as the dominate soul and then absorb all their memories about what happened when he was each of those people. Either way, it should be interesting to see how all this affects Sam going into Season 7 with all this knowledge about himself now. But as weird as it was to figure out what the hell was going on in the early goings of “The Man Who Knew Too Much” I thought it was pretty cool how Sam regaining his full soul and complete memory went down.
Something I liked and didn’t like at the same time was what happened with Lisa and Ben. When we started the season, Dean was living his new life with Lisa and Ben with Sam in hell (so he thought.) By the end of the season, Lisa and Ben, literally don’t know who Dean is anymore and it’s safe to say they are gone from his life for good. While I am glad the Lisa and Ben storyline looks to be over and done with, I’m not sure I like how it went down. I heard on a podcast and I completely agree that wiping away Lisa and Ben’s memories really didn’t help them at all and in fact, may have put them in more danger. Castiel felt horrible about what Crowley did to Lisa and Ben so Cas did two things….saved her life and wiped the memories of Lisa and Ben so they couldn’t remember Dean and everything surrounding him. While I wouldn’t have a problem if they wanted to wipe their memories of her current boyfriend and his death and their kidnapping, they shouldn’t have wiped the memories away of Dean completely. The monsters that come after Dean will still know that Lisa and Ben mean something to him whether they have their memories or not. So instead of being able to use some of the tricks Dean taught them so they can protect themselves, they won’t know that anymore because their memories are gone. And I understand that this was done more so to wrap up the Lisa and Ben storyline for Dean and not have it hang out there anymore, but it still doesn’t make sense. I know I’m nitpicking and they ultimately accomplished what they wanted…ending the Lisa and Ben story. I just think it could have been handled better because technically, they really aren’t out of his life because evil can still go after them because Dean will always care about them. Having said all that, it was a sweet gesture for him to want to get their lives back to normal. It was crushing for him but, in Dean’s mind, it was better for them that they don’t know him and they don’t know what’s out there. And now they can move forward peacefully with their lives. One can hope.
As for Castiel and his mission, I don’t know what to think. I’ve said it before, I’ll say it again, I’m not a Castiel fan. I don’t hate the character, I just don’t have this overwhelming Castiel love that some people do. I mean people go crazy for this guy and I don’t get it. He’s a good character and over the last 2 seasons, I’ve liked the relationship he’s built with Sam and Dean. But that’s it. I think there have been much better characters on the show than Castiel (and much worse) but the heart of the show for me will always be Sam, Dean, and Bobby. Not Castiel. So his betrayal of Sam and Dean (if you want to even call it that) didn’t bother me as much because I always felt like as much as Castiel really likes the Winchesters, he would always put his love for God and the greater good, first. As he should! But this war in Heaven took it to a whole new level. In fairness to Castiel, even though he made some questionable decisions that led him down a dark path, his goal was always to save the people. Raphael wanted the apocalypse to happen and wipe out man kind so he can start all over again. Castiel didn’t want that to happen. You could argue, it’s because he cares about the Winchesters so much. Before he met them, maybe he would have been on Raphael’s side and not cared so much. But I doubt it. That doesn’t seem to be who Cas is. But lately Cas showed many different sides to him so who knows at this point. Deep down though, I think Castiel would have wanted to stop Raphael’s plan regardless of his connection with the Winchesters or not. What I still don’t understand is why they are being so hard on Cas. Both Sam and Dean have made deals with demons before to save someone they love and because they thought the end justified the means. So why can’t they see that with Cas? Cas is only working with Crowley so he can save Heaven from Raphael and therefore hundreds of millions of people. But Castiel’s biggest problem and where I stop defending him is that he crossed too many lines in his quest for salvation. And you have to wonder, at what point did this stop being about saving people and start being about a power trip for Castiel? Because in my opinion, that’s what happened.
It started back in Frontierland when he had Balthazar unsink the Titanic to be able to kill more people who shouldn’t have lived (his justification) to get more souls. Once he found out about the way to open the portal to Purgatory (the blood of a virgin, the blood of a creature from Purgatory, and some latin) he went on a murderous rampage. He killed Ivy Crane and some virgin probably. Then to distract Dean, he took down Sam’s wall. Castiel was down right evil. So right before our eyes, Castiel was becoming a darker and darker entity. It could be because he felt alone and that everyone betrayed him. Rachel was his lieutenant but she betrayed him (in his eyes because we don’t really know what happened.) The Winchesters betrayed him by not being on his side and fighting against him. Balthazar betrayed him by going behind his back and telling the Winchesters about his plan so they could stop him. And Raphael was never on his side. It makes you wonder if anyone in Heaven was on Castiel’s side or did he become a rogue force. From his standpoint, he had no one supporting him anymore so he was going to do whatever he though necessary to defeat Raphael.
Once Cas and Crowley had the blood and latin they needed they were ready to open the gate to Purgatory. Only one problem, Cas doesn’t want Crowley around anymore so he hustles him away. Crowley, being Crowley, does the only thing he can do….he now sides with Raphael to defeat Castiel. When he shows up with Raph, he gives Cas the same ultimatum Cas gave him…flee or die. So Cas flees but not before he swaps out the real blood for fake blood so Crowley and Raph can’t open the gate. When he comes back to rub it in their faces, he tells him he opened the gate and now all the souls in Purgatory are inside of him making him one powerful son of a bitch! Crowley gets out of there real fast and Castiel kills Raphael with a snap his fingers. Bobby and Dean are there to witness the whole thing and we are seeing a new Castiel. Dean is shocked and tells him that they should get those souls out him so he doesn’t explode. He refuses. Meanwhile Sam has woken up and stumbles in with an angel sword and stabs Castiel. It doesn’t work. It’s because, according to Castiel, he is their new God. If they chose not to believe in him or follow him, then they can all die. Alrighty then!!! This is right around the time the real God should show up and put Castiel in his place….and fast!!!!
I don’t know if Castiel can be redeemed at this point (I’m sure the writers will find a way) but I do know his relationship with the Winchesters will never be the same. This is where I can finally empathize with Dean. Once Castiel purposely took down Sam’s wall knowing what it could do to him so he could distract Dean, he would be dead to me. I can’t see Dean or Sam forgiving that. I don’t think I can. Castiel may be at the point of no return. And with all the power he now has with all the souls inside him, he becomes a very scary individual.
What does all this mean for Season 7? Well, right off the bat the boys are going to have two things to deal with…first, Sam’s wall being down so now he remembers EVERYTHING and how that will affect him and second, Castiel walking around Heaven thinking he’s God but being a very powerful entity with lots of different sorts of souls inside him. I don’t think the types of souls inside Castiel have any affect on his decision-making, I just think it makes him one very powerful pain in the ass. First thing I hope for with Season 7 is a succinct, solid arc that is clear from the beginning to the viewers. The second is that I hope is that the arc isn’t fixing Castiel. That can be part of S7 but it better not be the main arc. And third, continuing the individual monster hunts that build and connect to the main arc. That’s what I want to see. Overall, season 6 wasn’t my favorite. In fact it was my least favorite. But I still love the show and have a lot of faith in the story telling and the cast. I already have lots of hope for Season 7. And hey, every show is due a clunker of a season right? Well now they have it out of their way and they can get back to what makes them great….solid, fascinating story telling with a stellar cast that can make you laugh or cry at the drop of demon blade.